Payroll Tax Cut Fight: ‘Wall Street Journal’ Editorial Rips Boehner, McConnell
The Wall Street Journal opinion piece passes out the business-centric blinders.
“No employer is going to hire a worker based on such a small and temporary decrease in employment costs, as this year’s tax holiday has demonstrated. The entire exercise is political, but Republicans have thoroughly botched the politics.”
True, but not the point of the exercise. Employers will hire when they see customers with money coming their way – which is the point of the tax holiday: Putting more money in consumer pockets. Wasn’t it the republicans who said that people know best how to spend their own money? Conservatives consistently devalue the necessity of funding the demand side of supply and demand. Instead, they are aggressively working to weaken the economic foundation of the middle class.
“Their first mistake was adopting the President’s language that he is proposing a tax cut rather than calling it a temporary tax holiday. People will understand the difference—and discount the benefit.”
So people will understand when it comes time to end the Bush “tax holiday” for the rich?
“Republicans have also achieved the small miracle of letting Mr. Obama position himself as an election-year tax cutter, although he’s spent most of his Presidency promoting tax increases and he would hit the economy with one of the largest tax increases ever in 2013. This should be impossible.”
Except that Obama44 has been cutting taxes. The “tax holiday” in question is only one example. Conservatives keep changing the definitions. Either the House republicans have voted for a middle-class tax increase, or we need to end one of the largest unfunded tax holidays ever.
Conservatives are nibbling at the edges of doublethink. The Obama44 cuts to payroll taxes and the Bush43 income tax cuts to income taxes are both temporary cuts. There is one notable difference between the two though. The Obama cuts are being paid for – how is a major point of contention. The Bush43 cuts went straight to the national debt.
The President and the Democrats want the rich to pay for extending the payroll tax cuts, and put some of that idle money back in circulation as an economic stimulus. The republicans want the middle class and poor to pay for it, which would negate the simulative effect and hurt the economy in the long term. Redistribution of wealth at its most ineffective.
Read the Article at HuffingtonPost
Related articles
- Republicans lose the Wall Street Journal on tax cut ‘fiasco’ (dailykos.com)
- WSJ: GOP botched tax debate (thehill.com)
- How the Republicans lost the upper hand in payroll tax debate – Washington Post (blog) (washingtonpost.com)
- House GOP takes beating over payroll tax (cbsnews.com)
- House Passes Bill… for New Churchill Bust (newser.com)
- GOP senator says Republicans need to resolve payroll tax fight and ‘move on’ (thehill.com)
- Romney Boldly Refuses To Take Sides On Payroll Tax Holiday (alan.com)
December 21, 2011 - Posted by Zera Lee | 2012 Election, Campaign Strategy, Economics, Legislation | 112th Congress, 2012 Election, Barack Obama, Class Warfare, Conservatism, Direction, Economy, Employment, House, John Boehner, Obama, Partisanship, Tax, Tax holiday, United States Congress, Wall Street Journal
1 Comment »
Leave a comment Cancel reply
About
Like most people, I spent the first part of my life focused on education, building a career, and building a life. It left little time to pay close attention to politics. But with the turn of the decade, the turn of the century, the turn of the millennium, I saw evidence of a change in the country so radical that I could no longer ignore it. It is time for the silent majority to be silent no more, and this is my contribution to our future as a nation.
Pages
Top Posts
- Four Reasons Elizabeth Warren Should Not Run For President
- Brian Sims, Pennsylvania Lawmaker, Silenced On DOMA By Colleagues Citing 'God's Law'
- Georgia Legislators Want To Change 17th Amendment, End U.S. Senate Elections
- Mitt Romney Makes 'Redistribution' Argument, Bolstered by Fox News, Conservative Media
- Bobby Jindal Appeals Ruling On Bernette Johnson, Black Supreme Court Justice
-
Recent Posts
- Four Reasons Elizabeth Warren Should Not Run For President
- Brian Sims, Pennsylvania Lawmaker, Silenced On DOMA By Colleagues Citing ‘God’s Law’
- Georgia Legislators Want To Change 17th Amendment, End U.S. Senate Elections
- Mitt Romney Makes ‘Redistribution’ Argument, Bolstered by Fox News, Conservative Media
- Bobby Jindal Appeals Ruling On Bernette Johnson, Black Supreme Court Justice
Most Read
- 112th Congress 112th United States Congress 2010 Election 2012 Election American Dream Arizona Attack Ads Barack Obama Business Campaign Finance Capitalism Chamber of Commerce Chris Christie Citizens United Class Warfare Conservatism Corporate America Democracy Direction Economy Education Employment Energy Environment Eric Cantor Filibuster First Amendment Fox News Channel Freedom of Religion Free Market Gay Rights Glenn Beck God GOP Government Health care Health Care Reform Insurance INTERPOL Islam Jim DeMint Joe Miller John Locke Journalism Judicial activism Labor Law Leadership Marriage New Jersey Obstruction One Nation Under God Partisanship Paul Krugman Philosophy Politics Real estate Regulation Religion Reproductive Rights Republican Republicans Same-sex Marriage Scott Walker Senate Separation of Church and State Sharron Angle Sovereignty Taxes Tea Party Traditional Marriage United States Congress United States Constitution Wasteful Spending Wisconsin
More Zera
Save the American Dream
Reclaim Michigan
Archives
- January 2015
- June 2013
- February 2013
- September 2012
- August 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- March 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
- August 2010
- July 2010
Categories
- 112th Congress
- 2012 Candidates
- 2012 Election
- Administration
- Budget
- Campaign Finance
- Campaign Strategy
- Candidates
- Capitalism
- Citizens United vs FEC
- Common Defense
- Congress
- Constitution
- Crime
- Democrats
- Direction
- Economics
- Education
- Elections
- Environment
- Ethics
- Evolution
- First Amendment
- Foreign Relations
- Gay Rights
- General Welfare
- GOP
- Governance
- Government
- Health Care
- Journalism
- Labor
- Legislation
- National Defense
- Personal Notes
- Private
- Regulation
- Religion
- Rewrite
- SCOTUS Rulings
- Second Amendment
- Social Security
- Strangelove
- Supreme Court
- Transportation
- Uncategorized
- Unions
- Voter ID
- Women
Government Links
Gov Resources
- GPO Bill Locator – Fed Digital Sys
- Senate Roll Votes
- Federal Register
- Gov Printing Office
- Thomas
- US Gov Manual
- Library of Congress
- National Archives
- Financial Report of US Gov
- CIA World Factbook
- Declaration of Independence
- US Constitution
- Bill of Rights
- The Federalist Papers
- Magna Carta
- John Locke: A Letter Concerning Toleration
Other Resources
Other Blogs
RSS Subscription
-
Join 7 other subscribers
Meta
Question, how can we blame anyone when the democrats control 2/3 of the government, the Senate and the Presidency. The Democratic controlled Senate has blocked over 20 bills that the house has tried to get to the President. I don’t think the issue here is liberal views versus conservative views, its a power struggle and a ineffective congress. Too much finger pointing and not enough mediation. We need sustainable development not more redistribution from this hand to that. It all spends the same regardless of who’s hand its in. Right, a dollar is a dollar, it only buys a dollars worth. I think both parties have good ideas, but we need to forge those ideas together and clear a path forward. Its like trying to push the opposite ends of a magnet together.
Comment by Canteen Contributor | December 21, 2011 |